Peer Review, Evaluation of Peer Review, Emulations, Return of the Grid
November 13th, 2008Last evening Arts and Sciences 095 students heard presentations from Lila, Rachel and Stephanie F. who talked about the artists they are researching, and the drawings they are doing using these artist’s styles. You can see some emulations of several other students below (Dali, DaVinci, Matisse cut outs, etc.).
We then went over to the Davis Center (4th floor – see pictures below) where students met in groups of three to read their papers to each other and critically comment. An anonymous written evaluation of this hour afterwards showed that while many students learned from reading their papers out loud, and a few got some feedback, many others felt this peer review exercise was not particularly valuable because students in their group did not know how to provide constructive criticism. So my overall perception is that this exercise has some, but limited, value. I think everyone enjoyed getting out of Cook building for awhile and there was, I saw, a short collaboartive dinner break on the second floor prior to paper readings upstairs.
After our time at the Davis center we returned to the classroom where students worked on finishing up their grid exercises, or doing emulations for their papers.
The pictures below are samples from the afternoon/evening. If your picture or your work is not shown, let me know. I keep trying to get everyone in, but posting time, lighting, and a variety of conditions constrain these efforts.



























